Not Everything in Fitness Needs to Be Optimised

Beyond the Reps | Lessons I've Learned

Somewhere along the way, looking after ourselves became another full-time job.

We need to optimise our sleep. Track our steps. Time our meals. Monitor our recovery. Hit our macros. Manage our cortisol. Perfect our morning routines.

And apparently, if we're not drinking electrolytes from a $70 water bottle at 5 am, we're already behind.

Don't get me wrong.

I'm a competitive bodybuilder and a sports nutritionist.

I love data, structure and understanding how to get the most out of the human body.

I've spent years deliberately manipulating training variables, nutrition and recovery to achieve very specific outcomes.

But there's something I've come to appreciate more and more.

Just because something can be optimised doesn't mean it needs to be.

Precision has a purpose.

When you're preparing for a bodybuilding competition, small details can matter.

Training execution. Nutrient intake. Fatigue management. Recovery. Consistency.

All of these contribute to the outcome you're working towards.

And when the goal is to present the best possible physique on a particular day, the level of precision required can be significant.

But that level of precision comes with a cost.

Time.

Mental energy.

Flexibility.

Sometimes your social life.

And while those trade-offs might be entirely appropriate for a competitive athlete during a specific phase, they aren't automatically necessary for someone who wants to build muscle, improve their health or feel better in their body.

Yet somehow, we've started treating elite-level optimisation as the standard everyone should aspire to.

And frankly, I think we've made something relatively straightforward unnecessarily complicated.

More information isn't always more useful.

We have access to more health and fitness information than ever before.

And that's a good thing.

We understand more about exercise physiology, nutrition, recovery and human performance than previous generations ever had access to.

But having access to information and knowing what to do with it are two very different things.

People can spend an extraordinary amount of time worrying about details that make very little difference to their actual results.

The perfect time to consume protein.

Whether their morning coffee is affecting their cortisol.

If they're training in the optimal heart rate zone.

Whether eating a banana at 8 pm is somehow different from eating it at 8 am.

Meanwhile, they're sleeping five hours a night, skipping meals and training without any real structure.

We've become very good at obsessing over the details while occasionally ignoring the bloody obvious.

And the fitness industry certainly hasn't helped.

There's always another product, another protocol or another supposed breakthrough promising to take your results to the next level.

Because apparently, consistently doing the basics well isn't nearly as marketable as convincing people they're missing some secret advantage.

The basics aren't exciting. They're effective.

If your goal is to build muscle, improve your body composition or become stronger, there are some fundamental principles that deserve most of your attention.

Appropriate resistance training.

Sufficient nutrition to support your goal.

Adequate protein intake.

Recovery.

Consistency over time.

The specific application will differ depending on the individual, their training experience and their objectives.

But those fundamentals remain important.

You can debate the finer points of nutrient timing all day.

But if you're consistently under-eating protein or failing to meet your overall nutritional requirements, the precise timing of one meal probably isn't your biggest problem.

You can spend hundreds of dollars monitoring your recovery.

But if you're regularly sleeping five hours a night, you probably don't need another device to tell you there's room for improvement.

And you can obsess over the perfect training split while completely ignoring whether you're progressively improving your performance.

Sometimes the answer isn't more complicated. It's doing the important things consistently enough for them to actually work.

The difference between precision and perfectionism.

This is something I think deserves more attention.

Precision can be incredibly valuable.

It allows us to control variables, evaluate outcomes and make informed adjustments.

Particularly in competitive sport, where small differences can matter, precision is often necessary.

But perfectionism is something different.

It's when the desire to do things correctly starts making it harder to do them at all.

When someone avoids eating out because they can't accurately track the meal.

When a missed workout becomes a reason to abandon the entire week.

When someone spends so much time researching the optimal approach that they struggle to commit to a perfectly reasonable one.

At that point, the pursuit of optimisation may be creating more problems than it's solving.

And I think it's worth asking a fairly simple question.

Is this level of detail genuinely improving your outcome, or is it just making you feel like you're doing more?

Because those aren't necessarily the same thing.

What bodybuilding has taught me about knowing when to pull back.

Competitive bodybuilding has taught me an enormous amount about discipline, structure and the value of paying attention to detail.

But it's also taught me that those demands are specific to the goal and the phase you're in.

The level of precision I might apply during contest preparation isn't necessarily the level I need throughout the entire year.

And it certainly isn't the level everyone needs to apply to their everyday life.

There are times when tracking food closely makes sense.

There are times when a more flexible approach is entirely appropriate.

There are times when training variables need to be managed with considerable precision.

And there are times when maintaining a consistent, well-designed routine is more than sufficient.

Neither approach is inherently superior.

The appropriate level of precision should be determined by the goal, not by how complicated you can make the process.

That's a distinction I wish more people understood.

Sometimes good enough is actually good enough.

Now, I can already hear the argument.

"But surely if something can be improved, we should try to improve it?"

Sometimes, yes.

But every additional layer of optimisation requires something from you.

Time, attention, money or mental energy.

And those resources aren't unlimited.

If a particular strategy offers a meaningful benefit towards a goal that matters to you, the investment might be worthwhile.

But if the potential benefit is tiny and the cost is substantial, it's worth questioning whether that strategy deserves your attention.

Especially when there are bigger, more influential factors that still need work.

You don't need to treat every meal like a laboratory experiment.

You don't need to monitor every physiological variable.

And you certainly don't need to turn looking after your health into another source of constant stress.

The takeaway

The longer I've worked in this industry, the more I've come to appreciate knowing when precision is necessary and when it's simply adding complexity.

I still love the science.

I still value structure.

And I absolutely believe in making informed decisions that help people achieve better outcomes.

But I also believe we need to get better at distinguishing between what matters and what merely sounds impressive.

You don't need to optimise every aspect of your life to make meaningful progress.

You need to understand which things matter most, give those things the attention they deserve, and stop turning every minor decision into a scientific experiment.

Because sometimes a banana is just a banana.

It doesn't need a bloody protocol.

— Kelly Greenslade
KG Performance

The science. The experience. The thinking behind the work.

Next
Next

Is Your Lack of Patience Killing Your Motivation?